Breastfeeding Myth – Many women can’t produce enough milk for their baby.

While it is known scientifically that most women can produce enough milk for their baby/babies (about 98%), many mothers in our culture feel it is a struggle to produce enough milk. Most women who believe they don’t have enough milk are reassured by talking to a volunteer breastfeeding counsellor or peer supporter. Often behaviour that leaves a mum feeling she does not have enough milk is very normal behaviour. Baby wanting to feed very often in the early weeks is normal. While some babies are happy to eat and sleep many others need to feed very often and be held in between feeds before they will fall asleep and be content to be put down.

However there are some women who are at risk of poor milk supply. These include:

Mothers with wrong or poor information about breastfeeding
Mothers of premature babies
Stressed mothers
Women who needed help getting pregnant (what made it difficult to get pregnant may interfere with their ability to make milk)
Mothers of a sick baby (baby struggles to remove milk from the breast)
Women who did not notice changes in their breasts during pregnancy
Very young mothers

Even many of the above mothers do go on to feed their baby exclusively.

Key things to keep in mind about the production of breastmilk are as follows:
*The more milk that is removed from the breast, the more there will be.
*The emptier the breast, the faster it will produce milk.
*The fuller breast will slow milk production until milk is again removed from the breast.
*Baby’s wants are baby’s needs.

One problem many women have is not understanding how long a baby can take to feed. A baby needs to double his/her birth weight between 4 and 6 months. If you had to double your weight how would you eat? Very often and through the night I suspect. Sometimes a feed is a snack, baby just wants one side. Other times baby wants 2 courses i.e. both breasts. Other times baby may want a multi course meal e.g. Feed both breasts for about half an hour (say starter and main course), have a snooze for 20 minutes, want pudding now that the first two courses have settled and left a bit of space. Feed for 10 minutes. Snooze for 30 minutes, fancies another portion of pudding, so feeds for 20 minutes on one breast and falls asleep for 2 hours (at last). Mum breathes a sigh of relief and lies down for a rest herself.

Women are often concerned because their breasts feel ‘empty’ i.e. their breasts feel much lighter after baby has fed and so there couldn’t possibly be any milk left if baby still wants to feed. Be reassured that each time baby feeds there will be milk available as most milk is being made during a feed. If baby is fussing on an ‘empty’ or light breast it may be because the flow is slower than baby would like. Don’t be afraid to swap sides at this point as the other ‘empty’ breast will have been making milk very fast and there will be some milk available at a faster flow.

It is no wonder women often don’t feel they have enough milk for their babies when our society has a distorted image of what babies really need i.e the perfect baby that feeds and sleeps in a pram for several hours. Most babies as I said earlier are not like this. Babies need held lots awake or asleep and most need fed often.
Women don’t need condemned for not breastfeeding, they do need a supportive environment in which to breastfeed and our society has a huge responsibility to provide this. After all ‘not breastfeeding’ costs everybody, breastfeeding being the basis of cost effective health care. As Dr James Akre says women don’t breastfeed, society does.

We need to stop blaming women for not having enough milk and become a society supportive of breastfeeding. How can we do that?
Be realistic about what new mums really need in terms of help and support. New mothers need help with the house especially food. They need to be allowed to rest in the weeks after birth and not expected to go shopping with their mother-in-law without the baby!!!
Instead of suggesting a bottle of breastmilk substitute, family members could bring round food instead – if this happened breastfeeding rates would no doubt soar.
Instead of suggesting a bottle of breastmilk substitute to improve weight gain (where weight gain is slow as opposed to what is called “failure to thrive”) health professionals could read about breastfeeding in a good breastfeeding book and advise accordingly, which again would produce improvement in breastfeeding rates.
Hospital practices could be improved eg encourage much more skin to skin.
Sleeping with your baby could be condemned less and safe practice could be encouraged. Skin to skin contact improves milk supply as does sleeping with your baby. Skin to skin contact can be done anytime mum and baby enjoy it.

So what can you do to help the women around you? Learn as much as you can about breastfeeding appropriate to your area of responsibility. The new edition of La Leche League’s ‘Womanly Art of Breastfeeding’ is a good place to start.
Read the ‘Politics of Breastfeeding’ by Gabrielle Palmer.
Join at least one of the breastfeeding support organisations.
Smile at a women with a baby, you don’t know what kind of a day she is having.
Don’t blame breastfeeding for all a mother’s woes – stopping breastfeeding swaps one set of problems for another often worse set of problems. Mothering is hard work so no wonder breastfeeding mums are tired.

If you are concerned about your baby’s weight gain or behaviour please do read http://www.llli.org/FAQ/enough.html, phone one of the volunteer help lines or contact your local peer supporters.

Sarah McCann.
Sarah is the only lactation consultant in private practice in Northern Ireland. She has also been volunteering with La Leche League for the last 15 years.

About Breastfeeding Resources NI

I am a lactation consultant in private practice in northern ireland. My qualifications are BSc(hons) and IBCLC (International Board Certifi
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Breastfeeding Myth – Many women can’t produce enough milk for their baby.

  1. Evelyn says:

    Hi Sarah! Thanks for the article! 🙂

    Can you maybe elaborate on why the types of women you mentioned might have more difficulty breastfeeding?
    It’s a little vague for some of them, e.g. very young moms. I assume you are talking about teen mums of 15-17ish with theor bodies having to cope with lactation on top of all the puberty changes? But maybe that’s not it at all, because I know some people consider myself a very young mom at 24! 🙂
    Same for stressed – death in the family sort of stressed or looking after new baby sort of stressed?

    • Hi Evelyn,
      Sorry it has taken me sooo long to reply. By very young mothers I mean those who have only had a very small number of menstrual cycles – never assume a problem though until it occurs. Experts say that stress should not be a problem, however blanket statements in this area are not helpful for individuals where stress is one of many factors. Stress probably affects the let-down reflex rather than actual milk production and all efforts possible should be put into reducing a mother’s stress – easier said than done.
      Best wishes,
      Sarah.

  2. Sheena says:

    Hello,
    I am a mother who fell into the unable to breastfeed category, I tried everything I could to nurse. I ate properly, rested and did absolutly everything the way I was supposed to. I even tried the Fenugreek and Blessed Thistle herbs and even went to the the steps of using the Donperidon drugs to up my milk supply, nothing worked. I was producing less than an ounce a day. I had tons of support, my midwife and husband were great supports.
    So Im sorry I do not agree with you when you say that anyone can and all women need is more support. Sometimes it just isnt ment to be for some women, so please dont say that everycan because they CANT.

    • Hi Sheena,
      I wrote the following in response to a comment to my article on another blog. The question was in relation to how accurate is the 2% who can’t breastfeed. I do hear your very raw pain. I hope the following answers some of your concerns.

      Hi Dr Sarah, Figures are very difficult to obtain on this as there is no perfect breastfeeding society to measure against. The 98% figure comes from the Norwegian initiation rates. However that doesn’t really say much about whether the mums can sustain breastfeeding or not. In Hungary the exclusive breastfeeding rates at 3 months have been very high at 92 to 93 %. Assuming some cultural drop off the figure of how many can produce enough milk for their babies is probably higher than this. However your question certainly leaves me feeling I should not have used the 98%, even if it were true as initiation does not prove sustainability.

      My bigger concern with writing the article was that most women who are told they cannot produce enough milk for their babies are told this with no evidence whatsoever other than cultural perception of what is the normal feeding pattern of a breastfed baby. There are some women who sadly cannot produce enough milk for their babies. It is a big enough problem that a book has been written on it – ‘Making More Milk’ by Diana West and Lisa Marasco. Many of these women who aren’t producing enough milk for their babies, if given good support and encouragement will go on to produce enough milk. Those who for some reason are unable to produce the full amount of breastmilk their baby needs can still give their baby what they can produce. This should not be seen as an all or nothing scenario. Every drop of breastmilk is important. Some women who cannot produce any milk at all will even feed their babies all the breastmilk substitute they need using an at breast feeding device as they know this is beneficial for their baby. Many women who cannot produce the full amount of breastmilk they need will also use an at breast feeding device to give the breastmilk substitute supplement their baby needs. These women deserve a medal for the huge amount of extra effort they go to to breastfeed their babies. I did not intend to trivialise the difficulties many women face in trying to produce enough milk for their babies. I was however trying to explain what is normal breastfeeding behaviour in my article as understanding this is a huge problem in our culture.

    • Anonymous says:

      Hello.
      I am in the exact same boat! My baby is ten weeks old now and I have been feeding every 2-3 hours, pumping after every feed, taking domperidone, fenugreek, goat’s rue, blessed thistle, brewer’s yeast, and eating oatmeal and drinking water by the bucketful/ Unfortunately, I just DON;T produce enough milk, and we have had to slowly up the supplements given. My baby now needs at LEAST 20 oz of formula supplement a day (which breaks my heart since I nurse him almost all day long) which he receives through a supplemental nursing system. With the pumping, I usually get about a quarter ounce to half an ounce, although sometimes I get nothing or just drops. Not all women can breastfeed and it is heartbreaking enough for those who can’t to accept it, without being judged by others. I have definitely tried hard. My friends , family, and even the many different lactation consultants I have seen ( I have even seen DR Newman, who is supposed to be the expert in this field) are all impressed that I am still going. It has honestly been the hardest experience of my life.

      • My heart goes out to you. But do remember that while your baby either feeds with a supplementer at-breast or receives even drops of breastmilk you are breastfeeding. Sadly not the way you had hoped, but you are still breastfeeding. Well done for persevering so long. Your baby is very blessed to have such a dedicated mum. Best wishes, Sarah.

Leave a comment